Home » The Bible and Beyond » Discussions » Discussions Archive » What Does the Soul Long For?
What Does the Soul Long For?
A Bible and Beyond Discussion
Monday, August 24, 2026
Facebook Event Page
With Rikki Liu and host Dr. Shirley Paulson
Introduction
Some of the passages we’ll discuss in this Bible and Beyond Discussion are difficult to hear. They use images that reflect the patriarchal world of late antiquity, and some of them are painful to modern readers. The excerpts include passages from one of the Nag Hammadi books, Exegesis of the Soul where the soul is portrayed as a woman who is repeatedly violated, abandoned, and shamed. These types of passages are not models for our lives today, but they’re important for our study because they bring us deep into the thoughts and questions of the people who struggled with them.
We’re going to ask “Why did early Christians believe myths about Psyche and Eros could help people understand their own spiritual lives?” We’re not sugar-coating these topics. But we are learning to discern a great depth in the ancient world. They weren’t just looking for information, but they sensed that the deepest healing is learning what or whom to love.
Bio: Rikki Liu is a PhD candidate at the University of Texas at Austin, Department of Religious Studies. While working on her Master of Arts degree in Religion and New Testament at Yale, she won an academic award and a fellowship for further studies. At the University of Texas at Austin, where she is now, she won the 2024 Bernadette J. Brooten Award for Scholarship in Gender, Sexuality, and Embodiment. During this discussion we’ll be talking about her paper, presented at the North American Patristics Society, this year in May. It is titled “Exegesis of the Psyche: Eros and Psyche in Nag Hammadi Codex II.”
Texts
On the Origin of the World (Exegesis of the Soul) II, 5
111
The first soul, Psyche, loved Eros, who was with her, and she poured her blood upon him and upon the earth. From that blood the first rose sprouted upon the earth, out of a thorn bush, to give joy to the light that would appear in the bramble. Next, beautiful, fragrant flowers of every kind sprouted upon the earth from the blood of each of the virgin daughters of Forethought. They fell in love with Eros and poured their blood upon him and upon the earth. Next, plants of every kind sprouted upon the earth, and they had the seed of the authorities and their angels within them. Then the authorities created animals, reptiles, and birds of every kind from the waters and they had the seed of the authorities and their angels within them. (transl. Marvin Meyer)
Exegesis of the Soul, NHC II, 6
128, 1 – 129, 4
Her Father on high noticed her. He looked down on her and saw her signing in pain and repenting of her prostitution. She began to call on him for help, and [she sighed] with all her heart and said, “My Father, save me. Look, I shall tell [you how I] left home and fled from my maiden’s quarters. Restore me to yourself.” When he sees her in this condition, he will consider her worthy of his mercy. For many have come upon her because she left home. (transl. Marvin Meyer)
Transcript
Shirley Paulson
Welcome, everybody, to the August 2026 Bible and Beyond Discussion. Tonight I’m really happy to introduce to you Rikki Liu. I met her this spring at the North American Patristic Society meeting, and her presentation was so intriguing to me.
I thought you’d be interested in hearing her, too. Ricki is a PhD candidate from the University of Texas at Austin Department of Religious Studies. She finished her master’s degree at Yale, and since she’s been at the University of Texas, she won the 2024 Bernadette J. Bruton Award for Scholarship in Gender, Sexuality, and Embodiment. I’m so pleased she could come and she could pause in her studies for a bit just to come and join us tonight to tell us a little bit about what she’s working on.
The title of her presentation is “What Does the Soul Long For?”
Really glad to have you with us tonight, Rikki. Thank you.
Rikki Liu
Thank you so much. I’m so happy to be here.
Shirley
So you know, it’s very interesting that, in case you haven’t put this all together, Eros is the Greek name for the Latin name Cupid; and Psyche, the word we often run across in our readings, is the Greek name for soul. So Eros and Psyche have a thing going on together here. And it’s not just a Valentine’s Day party. It actually becomes an issue of some of our extra-canonical texts that we’ve been studying. What a surprise! So, in fact, some of the passages we’ll be discussing tonight are difficult to hear. They use images that reflect the patriarchal world of late antiquity, and some of them are really painful to modern ears – or readers, or whatever we are. So instead of looking to them as models for our lives, we’re really asking, what are these writers trying to express that ordinary language just can’t quite capture?
Instead of skipping over them because they don’t sound inspiring for modern living, we’re going to see how they teach us how to understand the ancient world. That’s what we’re about. So we’re not sugarcoating it either, but by looking closely, we can discern a great depth in the ancient world. They weren’t just looking for information, it’s more like longing for deep healing, or learning what or whom to love.
So, with that kind of introduction, Ricki, could you start us off on this discussion with a quick review of the way that story is best known at that time?
Rikki
Yes, certainly. So, the story’s gonna be best known from a 2nd century Latin novel by an author named Apuleius, and the novel is sometimes called Metamorphosis, and sometimes it’s called The Golden Ass.
So the larger plot of the novel follows the central character named Lucius, and the central plot point is that he gets turned into a donkey, but kind of embedded within this story are several smaller ones. And probably the best known of these embedded stories is the story of Cupid and Psyche which introduces Psyche as the youngest and most beautiful of the king’s daughters, and kind of common to a lot of myths. Her beauty incites the jealousy of Venus, and so Venus sends her son Cupid to cause Psyche’s downfall. But Cupid is the one who falls in love with Psyche when he sees her, and so he takes Psyche away to his palace. And there in the palace she’s waited upon by invisible slaves, and she is only met by her husband during the night, and he is completely unseen by her. And as all of this is happening, Psyche’s family believes that she’s dead. And Psyche is really distraught about this and convinces her husband to let her speak with her sisters. And when she’s telling her sisters about her new life in this palace and everything that’s happening, they’re incredibly jealous.
And so they prod Psyche to discover her husband’s identity, and they convince her that she must have been tricked into marrying some kind of monster because he doesn’t want to be seen. And so at night, Psyche approaches the sleeping Cupid with a lamp, and she sees him and is so startled by his beauty that she pricks herself on one of his arrows and also spills hot oil from the lamp on him, and he wakes up and flies away.
Psyche then wanders the Earth looking for Cupid, and over the course of this time, she is at various points serving different goddesses, the final one of these being Venus, who is setting her impossible tasks that are only made possible by the aid of different creatures and gods that are really moved to pity by Psyche. And so the final task is a journey into the underworld where she is supposed to obtain a portion of the beauty of the goddess Proserpina or Persephone in a box. And she is able to obtain this, but is warned not to open the box. And she, of course, gives in, opens the box and is put to sleep, like an unshakable sleep. And then finally, we see Cupid find the sleeping Psyche again, and lifts her out of sleep, and then brings her up to an assembly of the gods in order to finally gain approval for their marriage, and then so the story ends with Psyche being given immortality, and ends with their wedding banquet.
Shirley
Wow, that was an amazing recap. Very nicely done, Ricki. So, you might be wondering, why are we going into mythology when we’re trying to study the Bible? But bear with us, because it’s amazing how these creatures appear in these extra-canonical writings.
To get our bearings here, let me just confirm here. Eros and Cupid are the same characters. Does Psyche have a Latin name, too?
Rikki
Eros and Cupid are the same, just the Greek and Latin and Greek versions. Psyche is the Greek word for the soul, but in Apuleius’s Latin novel, she’s still called Psyche, and she doesn’t really tend to be translated into a Latin equivalent, which might be something like anima.
Oh, and I saw a quick question in there, just to confirm. Yeah, Cupid is the son of Venus/Aphrodite, and tends to get sent out by her in a lot of myths when she’s jealous of someone to cause some downfall by making someone fall in love with some animal or something.
Shirley
Yeah, good. So, psyche is the same word as soul in Greek. Could we say that all the stories we read about soul pertain to the psyche, or is there something… is there a different name there going on?
Rikki
I wouldn’t necessarily say that every mention of the soul or every use of the word psyche is necessarily going to refer to this specific narrative. But it’s not that out there to think that if you hear the word, it’s easy to imagine in the ancient mind, a personified soul. So I can show here a picture that shows some images of artistic depictions of Cupid and Psyche that were very frequent in the Roman world, and they’re very frequently shown as these winged
figures like Cupid with these sort of feathered wings, and Psyche with butterfly wings. And they’re especially common on Roman funerary sarcophagi, that’s what the central image is here.
And so Apuleius’s story might be, like, the best preserved and most well-known version, but a lot of the artistic depictions, and some of these can be dated earlier than Apuleius’s writing as well, they generally kind of tell us that there’s, like, a broader imagination of the soul personified as a woman beyond just kind of this literary depiction.
Shirley
Wow, that’s really helpful. Yes, so I do recognize those images. So, many of our participants here have become acquainted with the Secret Revelation of John and we read about Psyche there. Is there any connection between that Psyche and the one you’re talking about or any other Nag Hammadi writings?
Rikki
Yeah there definitely is. For the soul, kind of as mentioned in the Secret Revelation of John, also called the Apocryphon of John, it’s, I think, especially helpful to think of that particular text as it appears in the manuscripts that we have. And so this particular text shows up in four different manuscripts, but I want to focus on the one that’s in Nag Hammadi Codex II, and in that text it’s bound together with two others that are really more closely tied to the story of Eros and Psyche. Those are going to be the 5th and 6th tractates from that codex that are called On the Origin of the World and Exegesis of the Soul.
Shirley
And just to stop you for just a second there, a codex is a collection of books that were in the Nag Hammadi collection, and that we have… we’re talking about different books inside that codex, right?
Rikki
Yes, the codex, I think, is the word just for a book that’s bound as books as we recognize them today, instead of being scrolls, and then within them are different texts all collected together.
Shirley
Good, okay.
Rikki
Yeah, so… “The Origin of the World” is gonna have the most explicit connection in the Nag Hammadi text to the Cupid and Psyche story, because it mentions the creation of Psyche.So it mentions Eros being created from the light and blood that the figure of Pronoia spills out upon the earth. And this Eros is described as the origin of sexual procreation in the created world. And the text describes all kinds of different species of trees springing up from this appearance. And then the text also describes the first soul, using the word Psyche, as loving Eros and also pouring out her blood upon the earth, and from this blood is springing roses and flowers as other daughters of Pronoia, which this first soul is also one of them, are also continuing to fall in love with Eros and pour out their blood, and so in this, they’re contributing to the creation of the Earth and its flora and fauna.
And then the text that immediately follows on the origin of the world is called Exegesis of the Soul, which opens by very explicitly kind of stating and like introducing the soul as a personified woman where it says, wise men of old gave the soul a feminine name. Indeed, she is female in her nature as well. She even has a womb.
So the narrative in Exegesis of the Soul describes the soul as falling into a physical body and engaging in sexual intercourse and being raped by robbers and adulterers until she repents and is healed and is brought back to her former kind of divine state through reunion with the father and the bridegroom.
And so the text does not explicitly pair the personified soul and the personified eros in the way that On the Origin of the World does, but it links to other depictions of this pairing and its focus on the soul as a woman with an emphasis on her sexuality, and it also will certainly call to mind the text that comes just before it in the same codex as well.
But also looking beyond these mentions of Eros and Psyche in these texts, various other earlier scholars have also highlighted parallels between Apuleius’s version of the story, with different accounts of Valentinian myth as recorded by authors like Irenaeus or Clement of Alexandria and these would all have been more available and that people were reading before Nag Hammadi was discovered.
Shirley
Oh, so these names then were familiar with the readers of these second century texts then, and these characters. Okay, so I think there’s a consistent theme in several of these Nag Hammadi writings that you mentioned, namely that the soul is longing for wholeness which is beyond the, like, the present situation. So are these stories really about women, or are they about human beings longing to recover something that’s been forgotten?
Rikki
Yeah, I would definitely say that they’re more broadly about humanity than specifically about being about women. And I think people might have come across before a lot of discussion surrounding the Nag Hammadi texts often focuses on what they might be telling us about gender or women’s roles in early Christian communities, and by extension, it kind of has bearing on what people are thinking about gender roles in the present. But these questions are usually coming from noticing that the Nag Hammadi texts do devote more attention to female figures than we tend to see in canonical texts.
But it’s not really straightforward to jump from representations of femininity to actual historical questions about women’s situations in the communities that might have been reading these texts, no less because it also proves pretty difficult to pin down things about which communities were reading these texts or why and how they were reading them.
And so I think it’s important to really focus on the representation of women in these texts, kind of in the broader context of what the texts are doing.
Shirley
Wow. Okay, I want to breathe. You’ve told us so much here. We’ll keep going, though. I think we should talk a little bit about Eros. Like most people today tend to think of Eros as sexuality itself, but is it something that’s strictly carnal, or is it actually love? That it offers a path to understanding.
Rikki
Yeah, so looking at the… I think it might be different between, say, the Nag Hammadi text and the way that they’re using it versus the way Apuleius is using it, and there’s going to be a variety of interpretations depending on what we’re looking at, but look at focusing on the Nag Hammadi ones. A lot of these texts really tend to focus around creation narratives, especially in Codex II. And so in On the Origin of the World we’re seeing Eros. Let me share this again. We’re seeing Eros really mentioned specifically in relation to the origin of sexual desire and procreation, kind of as you can see in this quotation. I’ll just give a moment if you want to read it.
Shirley
Can you read it for us all in case people can’t see it?
Rikki
Yeah, “just as from the midpoint of light and darkness, Eros appeared, and at the midpoint of angels and mankind, the sexual union of Eros was consummated. So out of the earth, the primal pleasure blossomed. Woman followed earth, and marriage followed woman. Birth followed marriage. Dissolution followed birth.”
And so if we look back at something like you mentioned before that you might be familiar with, “The Secret Revelation”, The Secret Book of John, or The Apocryphon of John, that one, along with some other texts in Codex II, are also describing the origin of sexual intercourse and procreation, especially with an act of sexual violence.
So here in The Secret Revelation of John, there’s an episode that reads, “the chief archon seduced her, and he begotten her two sons. Now, up to the present day, sexual intercourse continued due to the chief archon, and he planted sexual desire in her who belongs to Adam. And he produced, through intercourse, copies of the bodies, and he inspired them with his counterfeit spirit.”
Shirley
Okay, so, Ricki, help us here. Is sexual intercourse viewed as a source of evil, or is there something about real love that’s going on? I mean, it’s hard to understand.
Rikki
It certainly gets framed. I think it gets framed in these texts more so as an evil act because there is sort of an underlying kind of discomfort with the material world as it exists, and this is explaining how that came to be. And so, if you look back at On the Origin of the World, it has an overtly negative depiction of a violent depiction of this as well, where it says “they acted rashly, they came upon her–her being Eve–and seized her and cast their seed upon her, and they did so wickedly, defiling not only in natural ways, but also in foul ways.”
And so these texts really kind of emphasize an act of sexual violence as central to the creation of the material world and the creation of human beings as enclosed in physical bodies. And similarly, in Exegesis of the Soul, like I said, we don’t see Eros as a personified being. But the soul’s experiences of sexuality, especially violent sexuality, are very much located in this experience of the soul falling into a physical body.
So, I think it’s important to think about the representation of Eros in these texts, in this context of these creation narratives about the material world. And so we can think of Eros here kind of more as sexuality in the sense of being something that defines the material world as being really based in a cycle of sexual reproduction and death.
And so going back to the question earlier about whether these stories are actually about women, I kind of see the narratives of sexual violence not really being about women’s experiences of sexual violence, but more broadly about the experience of being an embodied soul and the kind of various traumas that one experiences because of the existing in a body. And along with that is sort of this sense of feeling alienated from something greater than one’s true self because of being in this physical state. And so this isn’t to say that people in antiquity or since then, women or not, might read these texts as speaking to experiences of sexual violence. But the texts are, I think, meant to be able to address a broader category of human trauma and alienation, while sort of seeking a way out of this, and kind of describing, like it says towards the end of The Secret Revelation of John, there’s how a soul can be “brought back safely into the pure light”. And so it’s certainly a different interpretation of Eros and Psyche than we see in Apuleius’ story, where Psyche’s longing for Eros and ascension to divinity to be reunited are framed much more positively then we might see Eros in the Nag Hammadi texts.
But we can also see, if we look at the history of these interpretations in scholarship, that there’s two different threads to how Nag Hammadi texts are receiving or echoing the narrative of Eros and Psyche as we know it from Apuleius, where the first is sort of tracing these specific figures of Eros and Psyche as they’re represented in these texts which is, like I’ve said, is closely tied to how they’re talking about the creation of the material world. And then the second thread, kind of rather than focusing on the figures of Eros and Psyche themselves, emphasizes more kind of like the general contour of the plot of symbolism of the story that kind of focuses on things like Psyche’s strong desire to see the face of Eros, their separation, and Psyche’s wandering through the world, her underworld journey, and then final ascent to join the gods and be reunited.
And so those are the points that tend to be more emphasized in the kind of interpretations that really highlight the parallels between this story and the Nag Hammadi texts that are understood to represent Sethian or Valentinian myth.
Shirley
Wow, so I don’t think most of us have thought about Eros and Psyche in the Bible as we read that, but now you’re showing us that it is quite prevalent here, especially in this Codex II.
Rikki
Thank you.
Shirley
Is there any connection then with orthodoxy or are we just missing it?
Rikki
I think for that question, I’m going back to the thought about how it’s interesting to focus on how these texts exist in the manuscripts that we have, and so…we can think about like the clues that we have about the actual Nag Hammadi books themselves, and questions about where, when, or why they were created and used. And so I like to think about it together with the largely prominent arguments about the monastic context for these books. And it’s really interesting to think about how they might have been read in a monastery. There have been previous arguments where people don’t think that they were read in a monastery because they’re like “Monks wouldn’t have read heretical texts”.
And then there’s other people who have suggested that maybe they had a collection of heretical texts that they were recognizing as heretical, just because they were like, “we gotta know about this, at least”.
But I think it tends to be more interesting to think about how there’s more reasons and ways that people read, rather than taking something as either scripture or taking it as something totally heretical. There’s a lot of room in between that for how people are reading. So I would say that it’s probably entirely possible that monks and other early Christians were reading these kinds of texts sort of alongside the more orthodox canonical texts. And not necessarily taking them to be either canonical scripture or as total heresy.
Shirley
So it’s like I envisioned this way, that there were people who were reading canonical things and they were being good people, staying within the boundaries. And then all these bad people who are reading all these extra X-rated writings in Nag Hammadi.
But you’ve sort of told us that people in general knew these stories, so did the people who are reading canonical things also know about them, but they just didn’t look at them? Or, I mean, I just feel like they’re in a bubble, that they’re not even connecting with them.
Rikki
It’s kind of hard to say. I think there are more connections than we might think, but this is kind of, like, an area in the scholarship that is certainly debated and, like, hard to pin down with super concrete evidence. But I tend to veer on the side of being, I think people read and thought a lot more broadly than we necessarily think they did, because our tendency is to simplify what we think about in antiquity.
Shirley
I think that’s why I’m coming at this idea of feeling like there’s a bubble here and a bubble here and they never met, but I think you’re right that there’s so much more going on that we’ve even thought about. When you gave your talk at NAPS, at the conference in May, you mentioned that there was a tendency in the 20th century scholarship to try to find some sense of universality in the interpretations of Eros and Psyche. Is there a problem with that? And if so, what is it?
Rikki
Yeah, I guess to answer this, I’m gonna try to give a little context about how people were interpreting these kinds of myths or the idea of Gnosticism in the 20th century, because my broader dissertation project is examining how people have interpreted Gnosticism over time, and something that really stands out about it is that people were almost always thinking about it in terms of what it means for their present. It’s even when they’re trying to theorize what Gnosticism is in antiquity, they’re thinking about, what does it mean for today, if we’re doing this kind of work?
And so an important piece of this intellectual history was something called the Erinos meetings that started in the 1930s. And they were hosted in Switzerland in the home of a woman named Olga Frobe Kapteyn. The meetings were gathering scholars in various fields, but they were generally all really interested in religious traditions, myths, and symbols, among other topics, and especially in thinking about and comparing these across geographical expanses across time.
And so, Carl Jung was someone who was a really central figure in these meetings, as well as other, like, really prominent figures in the study of religion that you might have heard the names of before, like Gershom Scholem, Mercia Eliade, or Gilles Quispel.
And Quispel is also the one who facilitated the purchase and publication of Nag Hammadi Codex I by the Jung Institute.
And so the scholarship that looks back at these Erinos meetings. They are thinking about this sense of apocalypticism in the early 20th century, especially around the First World War, and a sense of discomfort with the modernizing world. And so many of these scholars are thinking of their work as responding to a so-called crisis of the modern world. And it’s really prominent in how Jung was framing ancient Gnostics as sort of precursors to the people who were both dissatisfied with the idea of discarding things like myth, magic, and symbolism in favor of rationality. And also kind of uncomfortable with the idea, the prominent idea of modernity that was like rationality is the way to human progress. And so Jung was often framing Gnostics as early psychologists and people who were interested in uncovering the symbolism and images of their unconscious to sort of better understand it instead of rejecting that.
And so the paper that I was presenting at NAPS was looking at some parallels between these 20th century scholar interpretations of the myth and its echoes in Nag Hammadi and later authors. One of these later authors is Fulgentius, who wrote a large collection of allegorical interpretations of myth. I think there’s so many of these parallels that are telling me that 20th century scholars are so often echoing what ancient scholars and ancient authors were also doing when they’re trying to seek allegorical interpretations.
And like I said, Jung’s whole interpretation of Gnosticism is also framing them as people who are trying to interpret the myths that they are making as well. And so I think more so than trying to see if there’s a problem with trying to find universality in an interpretation. It’s more kind of about recognizing that scholars, everyone, are often trying to find universality because we exist in this kind of back and forth of projecting what we care about and what we experience onto what we study and what we understand of the past. And then while trying to understand the past, we also find ourselves mimicking a lot of it as well.
What I’m really interested in is this kind of constant back and forth. And so I think there would certainly be a problem with seeking universality in a way that’s expecting everyone to think in the same way. But if we look at how people have interpreted the Cupid and Psyche story and the Nag Hammadi text. I think we get more from it by thinking about the process of interpretation itself.
Shirley
Wow! Okay, you’re right. I have to confess that I keep looking for universality myself, too. You’re helping me to recognize my own habit of thinking, too, which I don’t necessarily know I’m doing, but that’s very helpful. And so, Carl Jung, you’re talking about a time before Nag Hammadi was even discovered, right?
Rikki
Yeah, yeah, certainly.
Shirley
Paulson: So, what was he interpreting then?
Rikki
So he would have been reading the early heresiographers’ works that were available and out there and transmitted. Probably towards the end of the 19th century is when the refutations against heresies that’s usually attributed to a Hippolytus. That’s when that was sort of uncovered from a monastery in Greece as well. And that was kind of being translated and published, and that shows up a lot in his references and what he was talking about. And there were also other things that were becoming available in his time, like the “Pistis Sophia” as a text was available in translation by that time, and so things were kind of starting to become more available and rediscovered in a way.
Nag Hammadi was sort of discovered towards the end of his life, and then he gets to see Codex 1 when it’s dedicated to him, and called the Jung Codex, but the rest of them weren’t quite available during his lifetime.
Shirley
Yeah, interesting. So, what would you say? Do you think, how has this myth allowed people to feel or understand about their own lives, even today? If it’s not universality, what is it that this myth is doing for people?
Rikki
As I was saying before, where it’s not so much that the myth is going to show us all one particular thing about our lives. It’s not going to be like this universal interpretation that works for everyone. But I think about how people have interpreted the myth. And the links between the different interpretations is kind of what gives us something to really reflect on, both in interpreting the myth for ourselves and in kind of reflecting on how we interpret as well.
Shirley
Okay, so, we are at the place where we need to open up the door and welcome everybody in and into the conversation. So, I just want to make a couple of announcements here. If you have not yet taken the hybrid version of the Nagamadi course, this is a great time to sign up. It begins on Tuesday, September 8th and promises to be a great conversation. Some of you have already signed up and you’re going to be in the class. I also want to just mention that if you have a question or idea for another discussion–like who we should talk to–please leave your ideas in the chat so that we have a chance to hear your own thoughts about this. I want to back up a little bit. To go to the Nag Hammadi course, you would go there by going to bibleandbeyond.courses/nag-hamadi to get the information.
Peggy, I saw your hand up, and you always have important things to say, so I need to start with you, Peggy. Go ahead.
Peggy Williams
Well, there’s just a lot of interesting questions, and I would say that Luca has spent some time thinking about this, and he’s got some good questions. And I’m asking Luca, do you want to just bring your questions to her or do you want me to read them?
I was starting with one of the early ones about arrows as it relates to Apollo striking arrows into the ground, but you take it wherever you want to. But you had some interesting questions.
Luca Seregne Bertani
That’s just something I heard from a sermon by Bishop Fulton Sheen, so I was just relating that. But more along the lines of, like, what Ricky Liu was trying to say of how we’re interpreting this is the interesting thing. But Toto was talking about how these things had to be considered in their context. So I was just considering
Who were the…how do I identify the groups of people who were really engaged with these texts. What was their inspiration? Where was it coming from? You know what I’m saying?
Rikki
Yeah, I mean, that’s kind of really the big question when it comes to studying Nag Hammadi. I think, like I mentioned before, the Apocryphon of John is the outlier here in that it appears in a few different manuscript copies, and also appears in the Berlin Codex. But the vast majority of these texts, they only…we only have them preserved in the one copy that was discovered at Nag Hammadi.
And what we know of the texts is that many of them were originally in Greek and then translated into Coptic. And we know kind of like the basic outlines of where they were discovered, and sort of some of the conditions of the discovery. And really that in a lot of cases is kind of…and that the contents of the text themselves is all we really have to go off of when it comes to trying to deduce who actually was reading these. And there are disagreeing theories about who exactly these were. But the one that I mentioned earlier–I think that has been sort of discussed most prominently–is the theory that these texts might have been read in monasteries and is coming from the evidence that they were discovered close to the site of a monastery from late antiquity. And there’s things like pieces of papyrus that were pasted together to make the covers of the books that contain some like monastic accounts and sort of documentary receipts and lists and texts that were pasted together and reused in that way. And there’s sort of scribal notes on the text that kind of use monastic language of brothers and whatnot that suggest that the scribes might have been monks, and…but that also still only tells us who created these specific copies, because then there’s the question of…well, these texts weren’t necessarily…they probably weren’t composed by these monks. Like we said, we think of most of them as having been translated from Greek, and so they all have a long transmission history before they find their way in these specific books.
And so that’s a whole other question as well: who was reading these other versions of this text? What did they look like in different versions? How did they get here, specifically? So it’s really kind of like a big, almost wide-open question of who was actually reading these? And sometimes we get bits and pieces of mentions in other texts; like some early Christian authors like Irenaeus and whatnot, they are mentioning the texts of the people that they are calling gnostics and heretics. And they mention things like the Gospel of Truth, and they mention things that show up in Nag Hammadi. And sometimes, in sort of comparing these, people are able to be like, oh, they’re talking about this one, so they knew about this one. But it’s a whole lot of many different bits and pieces of evidence that people try to piece together in different ways.
Luca
So would you say the classification of like some of those who are engaged with those texts as heretics, or the out-group, or, like, the wrong people could be that we have–like Toto was saying–the context that we’re getting this interactions dynamic from. Have you ever heard the “victors write history”?
Rikki
Yeah, yeah.
Luca
So, if these are collected texts that just ended up in a cave somewhere, right? I guess you could say there’s sort of a mainstream transmission of Christian doctrine and truth. And then there’s… Now, if you go back, like, what’s the earliest source you have identifying? You said Irenaeus is the earliest source we have identifying these are the people who are associated with that kind of…
Rikki
Yeah, he’d probably be one of them in the later 2nd century.
Luca
Something else. You ever heard the Apostle Paul said, “No one knows the things of a man, but the mind of a man in him”?
Rikki
I haven’t, I actually don’t.
Luca
“No one knows the things of a man, but the mind of a man in him. So too no one knows the things of the spirit. No one knows the things of God, but the Spirit of God in him.” So, it would be fair to say, when I ask what’s…judging by the content of the words, how it generally follows a certain thread. See the inspiration of it. Would you say that there can be a certain… What is it you said that your concerns, like what’s important to you, what drives you, what moves your emotions, will determine how you interact with a certain text. You were saying, so it’s hard for us to really see how people in the past were..where their inspiration was coming from.
Rikki
And kind of what I was saying before was that, if you think of the different types of texts that we read today and the different ways of reading, we kind of have an example of just how many different ways people do read. So, many people can read the same thing and get something totally different out of it. And that’s happening when people are reading the same thing today. So I think that’s kind of helpful to think about and imagine when we’re asking what ancient people were doing when they were reading these things, because I think we can imagine as much variety there as well.
Luca
And so, would you say the Nag Hammadi texts, did they come from an engagement with the same, like what you said, the biblical canon, or the tradition of the face…
Shirley
Luca, I’m going to step in here and ask. We have several other people with hands up that I want to get to. If we have time when they’re finished, then you can certainly come back, because you’ve got some great questions I want to hear. But we should also see what other people have on their minds, too, if you don’t mind.
Luca
Okay, okay.
Peggy
And I was going to add that I put in some links that Rikki recommended, Luca, and you can go check those out in the chat too.
Shirley
Thank you, Peggy. Yeah, thank you. All right, so, and Peggy, I’m counting on you to keep track of the chat, because I haven’t been able to watch that. And I’m going to go to Maureen right now, then.
Maureen
Okay, I have one specific question, but my other question matters the most to me. So my specific question was, what did Psyche do that landed her down in the depths of depravity? I don’t remember reading about what was the big boo-boo, I mean.
Rikki
I guess to start off in the Apuleius version of the story. It kind of starts with Psyche being so beautiful that everybody’s like praising her and saying she’s more beautiful than Venus, which never goes well for anyone. And so that’s what first gets Cupid sent to her, where the classic Venus move is to send Cupid, make someone fall in love with someone horrible, and make that be their downfall.
But then the next thing that Psyche does is try to see Cupid’s face when she was told and ordered by him not to try to see him, and that’s what causes him to flee. And Cupid is also kind of working under this knowledge that his mother does not like Psyche and would not be happy about them being married, and he’s also trying to cover all that up. And so, when she sees him and he flies away, then they’re separated. And it’s that kind of disobedience, sort of, that is kind of resulting in her wandering through the earth and doing these tasks and going into the underworld and everything.
Maureen
Disobedience, but also the fact that they were invisible and by wanting to see his face. She was trying to make him visible.
That would be a… Okay, my other one. Your title of this talk has just been in my thought for a long time. What does the soul long for? How do you study? How have your studies embraced that, and then how does it end with love? That it’s the deepest desire.
Rikki
That’s a great question. When we were kind of preparing this talk, we were sort of talking about how… I forget what I initially had as a title or something, but it was in sort of recognizing what was mentioned in the beginning of the talk, that a lot of these texts, and especially their depictions of sexual violence, they are very difficult texts, and they kind of seem intimidating to get into, because it’s hard to know, like, what to make of that in texts from antiquity. And so it was kind of in the reframing of the talk into thinking about this question of what the soul longs for, and that is sort of like how we landed there with that sort of title. And I think the way that that kind of question… Sorry you asked about kind of how that question is kind of brought into my work.
Maureen
Well, yeah, how did it narrow down to that wonderful title, and how they finally got what they wanted was love.
Rikki
I might be answering this in a different way than you were thinking about, but I would have to admit that when I was looking at these texts and first writing the paper that I presented, I wasn’t thinking about love. I was just looking at the text and looking at, sort of this intellectual history of gnosticism. But I think that’s still a good place to land, because I think as I’m doing scholarship that really focuses on sort of an intellectual history and reception history, the thing that I keep trying to remember—while looking at all these different ways that people have interpreted the past before—is to try to think about it in kind of empathetic terms and think about how people are approaching all these texts. Because there’s something that they care about in them, and something that they love in them, and something that they’re trying to find from that. And so I think it’s easy to look at especially some early twentieth-century, late 19th-century interpretations of things—they get really out there. And it’s easy to just read them and try to dismiss them, but it’s… but that’s the thing that I’m trying to remember while looking through all of these.
Maureen
Okay. Thank you. Instead of staying with the academic, we’re looking for the humane side of things. You got it. I mean, you answered my question.
Shirley
Yeah, why did people bother writing these things in the first place? What was driving them? So, yeah, it was really helpful, Maureen, to bring that up. Sujan, go ahead; it’s your turn.
Sujan
Okay. First of all, I want to say I really love your topic. I think it’s brilliant and, like, so deep. And I want to ask you what occurred to me when you started speaking. Have you read the book Till We Have Faces by C.S. Lewis?
Rikki
Yeah, yes. Yeah.
Sujan
Yeah, that’s pretty deep, especially from a Christian perspective. And also my…the other image that came to me while you were speaking is that the most popular sculpture of Caesar Augustus, who was the emperor when Jesus was born, shows him with Eros or Cupid riding a dolphin at his feet. And at the same time as it traces back to Virgil’s Aeneid, in which he claims that Caesar Augustus is son of God, because he’s related to Aeneas, who was also the son of Aphrodite, which would make Eros or Cupid his brother or so for their many generations. But yeah, that’s an interesting connection with Jesus because his image was out there, and it’s part of the cult of the emperor. And because of this image of Aphrodite, Caesar Augustus has “Son of a god” stamped on his coins. At the same time, this whole idea of Jesus being the Son of God is also kind of eventually evolving in the Christian tradition. Do you have any comments on that?
Rikki
I guess maybe this is going slightly off, but I think it, like, brings up some other things that I forgot to mention earlier, where there’s really interesting work also that looks at Roman literature, things like, um, the Aeneid or Ovid’s Metamorphosis and other kind of… like Livy’s History of Rome…and looks at sort of some parallels. Specifically, there’s a work by a scholar named Celine Lily, called The Rape of Eve, where she’s looking at these scenes of sexual violence in the Nag Hammadi texts and how they connect specifically to other sort of parallel scenes in Greco-Roman literature. And so there’s a lot of parallels and a lot of connections that come up across these texts that we wouldn’t necessarily expect to see. And it’s super interesting as well, too, because the two texts that I was focusing on On the Origin of the World and Exegesis of the Soul kind of really draw on sort of Greco-Roman mythology and literature to an even greater extent than a lot of the other Nag Hammadi texts, sort of with the mention of Eros. And in Exegesis of the Soul, there’s even quotations from Homer, from the Odyssey, I believe, because there’s kind of comparisons of the soul longing for the father and the bridegroom being compared to Odysseus longing for home, or Helen kind of regretting her being brought to Troy and longing for her home and her husband as well. And so there’s these really fascinating kind of intertextual connections across these.
Shirley
Brings it back to the moral longing again, doesn’t it? Very interesting. Thank you, Sujan. Very helpful questions. Katie, go ahead, your turn.
Katie Grigg-Miller
I have two questions. One of them is that I’m just feeling pretty lost as to what any of this means, because I don’t have any background knowledge in Greek mythology. So, this is all kind of going over my head, and I would really like to understand a little bit about what these two passages mean that were in the website. My other question relates to that is, how are they labeled, and where do we find this text online? I don’t understand the…It says there’s a, like, numeral 2, comma, 5, 1, 11. I don’t know what that means, and I’d love to know.
Rikki
Okay, so I guess for the practical question about how you sort of locate parts in these texts, there’s multiple translations of the Nag Hammadi texts that are available publicly online. The Roman numeral II that is going to be at the beginning of references to these texts is…the II is referencing that these are from Codex No. II. Each of the different codices from the library is numbered. So these are from Codex II, and then the number after that is going to be which number text they are collected in that codex. And so these are the fifth and sixth texts. And then usually a sort of page number or line number in the text. And so that can sort of help you find specific passages within the text.
Shirley
And you can find these online too. Yeah.
Katie
The only one I found so far is in othergospel.com, and that one just has a list of numbers 1 through 28, and so it doesn’t seem to correspond.
Rikki Liu: Yeah, sometimes the numbering can be a bit…
tricky. Let’s see, the one that I think Peggy shared links to or from the Early Christian Writings website, and those are translations of these, and those ones just don’t have numbers, I don’t think, for different passages. But you might be able to find the specific passages if we sort of scroll through them. But let’s see, you also asked specifically about the ones that were shared on the website for this discussion. I want to pull up what those were.
Katie
Yeah, what is the…why is she pouring her blood? What does that mean? And why is there a rose sprouting out of that and a thorn bush and then there’s joy and there’s light that would appear in the bramble. What does that mean?
Rikki
Oh, fair. They are very kind of oddly obscure. I mentioned earlier, On the Origin of the World is telling this kind of creation story, and is kind of in common to a lot of the other Nag Hammadi texts as well. The creation comes out of there being this first principle, who’s sort of the god above all else, and then things being created through… And then that sort of God is creating archons that are kind of both personified things, but also kind of just like concepts sometimes. And then the Archons then are creating other things, and there’s usually one Archon that is rebelling and wanting to create on her own, and by a chain of events, that is what results in the creation of the material world as kind of separate from this sort of broader, kind of like undescribable realm at first. And so the blood that’s getting poured out is sort of this motif that occurs throughout this text on the origin of the world. Repeatedly, there’s the imagery of like one Archon loving another. First there’s Pronoia, and then there’s the daughters of Pronoia, including Psyche. There’s different Archons loving other ones and wanting to create things, and that’s often described as a pouring out of blood. Or sometimes sort of a “gone wrong” act of creation described is also described sometimes in this text as like an aborted fetus, or like a not quite well formed fetus as well. And so that’s just like a kind of language and imagery that is sort of repeated throughout it. And that’s where we get this imagery of creation coming out of the pouring of blood.
And the description of the different plants and things is part of this kind of very, I don’t know, almost abstract way of describing the creation of the material world by talking about this plant, or another one, and how they’re all springing out from this blood. Does that make sense? It’s a very abstract feeling text. This one maybe even more so than some of the other ones. On the Origin of the World especially is a tricky one, but those are sort of just broad strokes.
Shirley
But Katie, I’m really glad you asked the question, because I think that what you’re getting at here that’s so important is: how do we understand enough of the motifs and the metaphors to be able to read these texts? Because they’re all over the place. And we need to know these sort of basic relationships in order to really read these texts and know what we’re talking about, so that’s a very important question. And thank you, Rikki, for helping us to get some kind of foundation for that, that’s really helpful. So, we’re moving along here, we’ve got just a few more minutes. Let’s see what Diana and then Honor…
Diana Austin
Well, all I can say is that when I’m listening to the original presentation it sounded so much like when in the early sixties– when the sexual revolution was starting to take place and I was in college–I remember my friends who basically had grown up in one of the various Christian churches and they got in college and Jung especially was very attractive to them, and they were all into this sort of thing. And that’s sort of what I was thinking of when you were saying that. I thought for a lot of these people, this is the first time they have even thought about anything other than what is physically out there around them. And all of a sudden there’s something more to how you’re supposed to be thinking about life and who you are. And that’s what it reminds me of.
Shirley
Thank you, Diana. That’s really helpful. But Rikki, you go ahead and respond to that if you want to.
Rikki
Yeah, I guess I wanted to ask a sort of follow up. So is what’s reminding you of that the process of how people are interpreting these texts or reacting to them? Or is it like the figures that are showing up within these texts themselves, like the arrows in Psyche?
Diana
Well, Eros and Psyche is the thing, okay, but it’s… I don’t think they were so much into Greek mythology or anything like that, but it was kind of like “Oh, there’s something more…” But it was more in terms of mythological, but not in terms of Greek mythology. It’s like…an explanation of who you are, and why you’re doing these things, or why you’re feeling these things. That’s what it just sort of reminded me of. It’s like you’re just trying to figure out what…you’re sort of lost.
Rikki
Yeah, that makes a lot of sense, and I think it really also speaks to how often people are reading Nag Hammadi texts, or the kind of parallels in the mythology of Cupid and Psyche with a sense of a strong motif of rebellion in some of these as well. Maybe that’s something that kind of really echoes with that sort of time frame and mindset as well.
Diana
Well, there’s also a lot of books that were coming out at that time that really sounded as farcical as the whole thing there. I mean, nowadays, everybody would look at it and say, why did you even look at that? Well, that was, you know, what was new and different. And I’m sure right now in 20 years, what we’re looking into or investigating, they’ll probably think, why did you even go there? That’s what I just feel like. And nothing is new under the sun.
Shirley
Ecclesiastes! Thank you, Diana, that was very insightful also. So, Honor, let’s see if we can have a quick question from you, and then we’ll finish up with Peggy.
Honor Haase
Well, as Shirley said earlier, this is challenging me to realize that I’m naive to think that the monks are sitting around just reading about God and Jesus all the time. Maybe on their breaks, they read mystery stories. And but, Ricky, did you–am I remembering accurately–that you said there was some codex that included some Christian texts, maybe the Apocrypha of John, plus some of these Cupid and Psyche things in one codex?
Rikki
The Cupid and Psyche sort of references that show up in Nag Hammadi are especially present in Nag Hammadi codex number two. So that’s the one codex that we’re primarily focusing on here.
Honor
So they’re in one, they’re bound together.
Rikki
Yeah, they’re bound together in this one codex here.
Honor
Okay, so this kind of story that you told us, the huge rambling story about Psyche and her wanderings.
Rikki
Yeah, that was the summary of the best known Cupid and Psyche story from Apuleius.
Honor
Yeah, but, but it’s still those characters and a story about those characters is bound together in a, what you would call Christian….
Rikki
No, the Apuleius version of the story is a completely different text, and that’s kind of just this Roman-Latin novel that is primarily where we know the story of Cupid and Psyche from. But that was not found at Nag Hammadi, not bound together with any of these other texts. But we’re just kind of looking at sort of the connections between them because they show up kind of prominently in the Nag Hammadi texts.
Honor
Okay, so I was thinking, if they were bound together, it would mean that the monks, or whoever, were actively comparing them, or connecting them in some way. But that’s not the case?
Rikki
No, we don’t have that…but kind of like I was saying before, what we do have in the Nag Hammadi texts are these references to a lot of other…a lot of references to mythology, quotations from Homer, quotations from the New Testament, and also, there’s an excerpt from Plato’s Republic that’s also bound in one of the Nag Hammadi books as well, so there’s a pretty wide variety in there.
Honor
Okay, and because all the Nag Hammadi texts were found together, we have reason to believe that pretty much the same group of people were reading all of this stuff or part of it.
Rikki
Yeah, they would have had to have been collected together at some point in order for them to have been found together in the way that they were, but it is also still kind of hard to say was one group of people reading all of these together in their libraries, or were they brought together at a later point, or… yeah. A lot of hard-to-figure-out things, but…
Honor
Yeah, okay. And humans like stories, so maybe monks just like stories even after they’ve read… they go to Prime and do their service, and then they have lunch, and then they go out and read about Cupid and Psyche.
Rikki
Yeah, maybe.
Honor
Okay, thanks.
Shirley
Wow. Okay, so Peggy, go ahead. I always need to hear from you.
Peggy
Yeah, we’re just going to slip in one more representation from Texas. This is actually from Toto in Denton. It’s interesting how no canonical texts were found with the non-canonical manuscripts at Nag Hammadi. Any comments?
Rikki
That is interesting. Yeah. I’m thinking now about the different Nag Hammadi texts. Yeah, not any New Testament or whatnot text. Like I said, a lot of quotations and references to them, but not copies of them themselves.
Peggy
And then there’s several more questions and comments. And where can people go look for that later?
Shirley
I believe that the chat can… I’m going to, when we turn off here, no, we have our reflections tonight. Let’s see.
Peggy
You can save it. You can print it and reference it later.
Shirley
But then I don’t know quite how to share it then.
Peggy
But I mean, if you wanted to do it in your Substack, if you wanted to do it on Facebook, where would be a good place where they could find those questions answered? I’ve put links for all those places.
Shirley
Good. I think Facebook is the best place to go, Facebook conversations. So, the Early Christian Texts conversations on Facebook is a place to do it. Thank you for saying that. I’ll collect them and put them there. And then, Rikki, I’ll see if you can answer some of those questions that are still there.
Rikki
Yeah, for sure.
Shirley
Okay, Luca, we are out of time. Do you have something you need to say right now, or can we put it in the conversation on Facebook?
Luca
Have you read Song of Solomon, verse 2…sorry, chapter 2, verse 17. I put it in the chat, the comments. It’s speaking of the beloved, until the shadows flee away, get you to the mountain of spices. So, maybe the fact that these non-canonical texts were found in a cave. Like a part. Maybe they were fleeing away. In a way, and have you ever had like…I don’t know. That’s all I can say.
Shirley
Yeah, oh, there’s so much more to say about this. Those of you who are Patreon supporters know that we can…we’re going to continue this conversation next week, so, we’ll have a great conversation. So, what happens then is people who are supporting us on Patreon are invited to a reflection. Rikki doesn’t need to be there, but we will have a conversation about all these questions next week. So, if you have not become a Patreon member and you want to be in the conversations, please go to patreon.com/BibleAndBeyond.
Shirley
If you join us on Patreon, then you are welcome to come to the conversation we’re having next week. So, wow, Rikki, you got us going here. Lots of things to think about with this, and I’m so grateful for you to be able to come and join us tonight. So, I’m going to close us out here.
This was the August 2026 Bible and Beyond discussion titled “What Does the Soul Long For?” with our guest scholar, Rikki Liu.
Thank you for being with us for our monthly Bible and Beyond discussion tonight. These discussions are led by a knowledgeable scholar who provides a thoughtful overview of some early Christian texts or issues. In the second half hour, participants have a chance to ask their own questions. We usually meet on the fourth Monday of the month from 8 to 9 p.m. Eastern Time.
And so now let me tell you what’s happening next month. We will meet on the fourth Monday, which will be September 28th. Dr. Craig Evans is coming to us to give us further insights on the Gospel of John and its relation to other Gospels in and out of the New Testament.
So now, please join me in giving a special thanks to Rikki for helping us to appreciate the feelings and meanings of ancient writings that relate to psyche, the soul. Quite interesting to think about. Thank you so much for being with us.
Rikki
Thank you.



Here are some beautiful words I found on the soul and its longing:
Our soul is a tiny fragment of the universal Soul, and it feels so confined and stifled by our physical body that its greatest desire is to expand throughout infinite space. So it is a mistake to believe, as people generally do, that the soul is wholly contained within us. In fact, this is not so: only a small portion dwells inside us. All the rest remains outside us and leads an independent life in the cosmic ocean.
It is important that you have a clearer idea of what the soul is and what its activities are. So, know that your soul is not limited, that it exists outside your physical body and travels to visit other regions of space and the entities that live there, while continuing to give life to your physical body. Our soul is infinitely greater than we could ever imagine, and that part of the universal Soul within us constantly reaches out towards space, towards immensity, towards infinity.
Omraam Mikhael Aivanhov