Home » The Bible and Beyond » Discussions » Discussions Archive » The Manichaean Story of Adam and Eve
The Manichaean Story of Adam and Eve
A Bible and Beyond Discussion
Monday, April 14, 2025
Facebook Event Page
Guest Scholar: Dr. Paul Dilley; Host: Dr. Shirley Paulson
Introduction
This discussion is about Adam and Eve, but from the eyes of the Manichaeans. The focus of the story is on the fashioning of Adam and Eve as a demonic scheme to imprison light particles within dark matter. This is a radical way of interpreting the story, making it look like human creation happened by evil agents of darkness. The goal of the demons was to trap the light particles, and the best way to accomplish that was through human reproduction.
This is where the community’s unique sexual ethics came from. To protect themselves from this evil imprisonment of light within dark matter, the “elect”—or the highest level of the religious community—were expected to practice total chastity. These were the ritual and scribal elite. A lower level in the community was known as catechumens, and they were expected to practice birth control. Everyone was called upon to do their best to prevent the entrapment of the light particles.
This Adam and Eve story from third-century Mani, the founder of Manichaeism, is key to understanding this distinctive teaching. We’ll find out why it has such an enormous impact, and the religions spread all the way across Afro-Eurasia.
Dr. Paul Dilly is the Erling B. Holtsmark Associate Professor in the Classics at the University of Iowa, specializing in the religions of Late Antiquity and particularly early Christianity. He’s also published numerous articles in journals and peer-reviewed volumes on ancient asceticism and monasticism. One of his well-known special areas of interest is with Mani, the founder of Manichaeism.
Text we used for this discussion (pdf file will open in a new tab).
Transcript
Shirley Paulson
I want to welcome everyone to the April, 2025, Bible and Beyond discussion. I am your host, Shirley Paulson, and it’s really fun to introduce our guest scholar tonight. This is Dr. Paul Diley. Paul is going to make a connection between the very familiar story of Adam and Eve and the very unfamiliar community of Christians known as the Manichaeans. So the title of our discussion tonight is “The Manichaean Story of Adam and Eve.”
I’d like to briefly introduce him. Dr. Paul Dilley is the Erling B. Holtsmark Associate Professor in the Classics at the University of Iowa, specializing in the religions of late antiquity and particularly early Christianity. He’s also published numerous articles in journals and peer review volumes on ancient asceticism and monasticism. One of his well-known special areas of interest is with Mani, the founder of Manichaeism. So welcome, Paul. We’re so glad to have you with us tonight.
Paul Dilley
Thank you very much. Glad to be here.
Shirley Paulson
I imagine that some of you may also remember that Jason BeDuhn was with us a while ago introducing us to the Manichaeans in another Bible and Beyond Discussion. And so tonight Paul is going to show us how the Manichaeans use the basic story of Adam and Eve to, I guess, basically explain the origin of evil in human experience and what humans can do about it. So even though the Adam and Eve part is so familiar, when we think about it, actually, that creation story of Adam and Eve in Genesis is really a strange story to start with. So it kind of makes sense to realize why other groups of thinkers in the first centuries tried to interpret it in more meaningful ways in their age. So Paul’s going to explain to us why it was so important to the Manichaeans and how it gave them a way to think about good and evil. So I think we have a lot to learn. I hope we can do this in an hour and we’ll see if we can boil it down to things that we basically need to know. So we need to probably start with a basic brief explanation. Paul, why don’t you tell us who the Manichaeans were, so that we can get into the story?
Paul Dilley
Sure. Yeah. So the Manichaeans are arguably the most important and most enduring of Christian heresies in late antiquity, at least if you’re not counting theological, Christological arguments that are still ongoing among different denominations. They’re a group, like the Gnostics, that existed, were vibrant and no longer exist for a variety of reasons. So their founder, Mani, was active in the third century, and he was not actually in the Roman Empire like the more familiar to the audience heretics would have been. So he was actually next door in the, what’s called the Sasanian Empire, which is the Sasanians who were the dynasty ruling Iran. So that’s like modern Persia, but also Mesopotamia, modern Iraq to the west of that, and then Pakistan, and Afghanistan. So kind of like a massive territorial expanse. Mani was in Mesopotamia, so he was a part of a baptizing group that spoke a dialect of Aramaic and were Christians who rejected the Pauline epistles.
Sometimes they’re called Jewish Christians. It’s a little bit complicated in any case for a variety of reasons. So Mani, at around 18, decided that his kind of horizons were much wider than this community. And he began, at that point, according to biographical traditions, experiencing his own revelations, talking about in particular, about this kind of eternal struggle between the kingdom of darkness and the kingdom of light. So if you want to get to the heart of Manichaeism, that’s often the doctrine that is most prominently pointed out and attacked by its enemies, even through the modern period, the Renaissance philosophers, they talked about Manichaeism not really as a community, but as this dualism. So that’s one aspect. The other aspect that’s really important is that while Mani definitely grew up in a Christian community, the most important revelation figure for him was Jesus. But as part of his kind of Sasanian heritage, he also recognized two other earlier prophets as particularly important. So Buddha was one of them. And Zoroaster, or Zarathustra in the Iranian language, is often seen as the founder of Zoroastrianism. So Mani saw these two figures alongside Jesus as important early revealers, and he is basically continuing in their tradition. But he was kind of reforming their traditions, which had been adulterated in various ways and providing the kind of final revelation of the kingdom of light.
Shirley Paulson
That’s a nice quick overview. So would you say, then, that Mani had a huge following when he’s mixing everybody together?
Paul Dilley
No, not a huge following, but he definitely… So he started small, right? Just a few followers from his community that he seems to have also been kicked out of. But this group of baptizers existed in various places in the Iranian empire, probably the borderlands with Rome as well. So he probably first started his missionary career in these communities, but definitely, he expanded outwards. He cultivated relationships with Iranian rulers. And so over a period of more than 30 years at least, he definitely created a fairly large movement. I mean, it’s just impossible, given what survives of ancient records, to estimate with any amount of accuracy. But it was large enough to then make a substantial footprint in the Mediterranean world and the West, and then in the east down the silk roots through Central Asia all the way to China. So it spread more expansively in pre-modern China than Christianity did, at least at first. So it had a highly successful career, if you want to call it that. It’s often kind of strange to talk about success as a metric for some of these, you know. How would you measure it exactly? But certainly his community spread far and wide, so it must have had a firm basis in his own career.
Shirley Paulson
Okay. So that’s very helpful to think about in terms of the fact that it had legs, and really something was very appealing about this. Since we’re getting into the main subject, as you’re bringing it up, we’re going to find out why this would be so appealing—when it’s so strange to our ears. They take the basic story of Adam and Eve and turn it into something that’s hardly even recognizable to us. So before we get into the details, maybe you should give us a sense of why they would even want to rewrite this basic and important story.
Paul Dilley
Well, so I should preface this by saying that a lot of Manichaean literature, in fact, the vast majority has been destroyed. The Manichaeans were persecuted in the West, and the Roman Empire, under the Abbasids in China, and eventually all over central Asia. So we only have, by luck, some survivors of Manichaean literature, or there are some in what are called ‘polemicists.’ So Christians who are writing against Manichaeism will sometimes quote a particular passage. And so Augustine, who is by far the most important Manichaean that history has left us (ex-Manichaean, of course, he eventually converted to Christianity in one of his writings). He quotes what he calls the Fundamental Epistle, and it’s a letter of Mani, in which he talks about how there are numerous stories of Adam and Eve, and pretty much anybody that you can think of has a story of Adam and Eve, and all of this publicity has caused the utmost confusion. So it’s up to him to set the record straight as it were. I would sort of preface all of this by saying that there wasn’t, by any means, a kind of single received tradition about Adam and Eve in the second and the third century. There are different interpretations of what we might think of as the biblical event. There were plenty of rewritings of it and what we call gnostic literature, so texts like the Apocryphon of John. So there are lots of different stories and interpretations circulating around that much of what Mani says is accurate. So he was essentially, no doubt, drawing on Aramaic traditions of Adam and Eve that are unknown to us or Christian, other Christian interpretations like the Apocryphon of John, for example. But he also looks at, there’s plenty of what we might call an intertext or an allusion with some Iranian stories of the first humans.
And he does that in a sort of clinical way against Iranian practices, in particular ‘xwedodah’, or next-of-kin marriage, which seems to come under attack in his kind of retelling of Adam and Eve. So there’s a lot going on here. And he also claimed this sort of special and final revelation. So he would’ve been drawing on all of these traditions and basically giving them the final seal of his prophetic imprimatur, as it were. But in doing that, he definitely was just one of many people talking, thinking about Adam and Eve telling more stories about Adam and Eve. He may have been different in this very programmatic claim to revelation, but he wouldn’t have been unique in that either.
Shirley Paulson
What’s so interesting about this, I think. is that you’re helping us to view a story that we may have heard, and that there’s one way to hear it, there’s one way to read it, and there’s only one story, and you’re stretching us to think that there’s all kinds of ways of looking at this story. I know that this particular way that Mani’s looking at this, the details in this story are really complex and way more involved than we can even get into tonight. But it seems like we need to know what happened before Adam even appears in the story. Is that right?
Paul Dilley
Yes, absolutely.
Shirley Paulson
Could you look at our bearings as to what was going on in the cosmos that led up to the creation of Adam?
Paul Dilley
Yeah, so in essence, there is, as I mentioned, a key aspect of Mani’s revelation was dualism. So the kingdom of darkness and below, and the kingdom of light above. In a sense, they’re co-eternal first principles, and eventually the kingdom of darkness, which is kind of characterized by chaos and various kinds of anger, disorder, but also ignorance. Eventually it discovers that, hey, there’s this kingdom of light above us and it attacks the kingdom of light, which is, in turn, characterized by order and virtue, et cetera. And so the kingdom of light: there are plenty of Manichaean attempts to describe its structure, but in essence, it is kind of ruled by the Father of the Lights as he’s often described. And so under attack, he kind of devises this counter attack. So he calls forth an emanation—like a lot of these gnostic accounts.
The Manichaean account is very heavily invested in this idea that you have this kind of, in essence, a simple Godhead. And then through a series of emanations in which various aspects of the divine character kind of become separate beings. This process is basically there in the Manichaean myth, but it’s wrapped up in this battle with the Kingdom of Darkness. So he calls forth the first man or primal man who is sent forth almost as a decoy or a sacrifice against the Kingdom of Darkness. The Kingdom of Darkness engulfs him. And so the light is basically captured by the darkness, and this represents the second stage of cosmic history, where we have this mixture of light and darkness, and the light that is taken by the darkness is in pain, suffering. It too suffers ignorance. And so the kind of cosmic goal, according to Mani, is eventually the salvation of all of these light particles.
So that’s what his revelation is intended for. And there’s a whole long narrative about various attacks and counter attacks between light and darkness, and basically the material world is set up following a counter attack of the light. The material world is set up as a kind of great physical machine, which is gradually intended to separate light particles, so up through the cosmic highway, the Milky Way, the moon, the sun. So they have this kind of very evocative, astronomical foe, of course. Although, they claimed empirical evidence to back up this revelation. But in any case, part of the background information is that we have all of these light particles entrapped in the darkness, and the Kingdom of Light has kind of set up this path of escape for the light particles.
Shirley Paulson
So then why would we even need Adam and Eve if all these things—if light and darkness are already having their battle and there’s a way for a light to be rescued, what’s the point of having Adam and Eve now?
Paul Dilley
That’s precisely it! So that’s what I would argue is really distinctive about the Manichaean story of Adam and Eve is that, so far as I know, it’s the only example where the creation of Adam and Eve is entirely a stratagem of the Kingdom of Darkness. So the creation of humanity is not something that is any way planned or participated in by the realm of light. It’s basically a strategy that the chief demon and his consort set up to further entrap the light particles across generations through sexual reproduction. So the idea of creating these humans who will basically, through sexual reproduction, continue the light particles within evil matter basically as long as humans exist. So, a bit of a downer, as it were! And definite, we’re going into a territory that might seem rather strange, but there it is. I think from the sources that we have, I think it’s pretty clear that’s what’s going on. And I could go into more details about the creation story if you’d like.
Shirley Paulson
I’m sure you could! Well, maybe we’ll have time to do that. But I think I first want to ask you: so are you saying that human production itself becomes a problem? How do they manage a whole society if sex is the problem?
Paul Dilley
Yeah! Well, I mean, so in a sense, the goal is ultimately the end of human society as we know it. The timeframe is unknown in a sense that they weren’t necessarily unique in this, of course. I mean, many early Christians assumed that human society, as we knew it, would be coming to an end soon, and that was a good thing. But the particular mechanism that, or kind of doctrinal stance that they had was, you could argue, if carried forward to its logical conclusion, would’ve been a good way to end human society, right? This idea that, well, there’s two things going on here because the Manichaeans had two major hierarchical groups. So on the one hand, you have the sort of elite ritual class called “The Elect,” and they’re the ones who participate in this thing called the Sacred Meal, where they escape light particles. And then you have “The Catechumens,” or in Latin, “Auditors.” That’s usually the term that’s used in English—what Augustine called them. But it’s the same word “catechumen” in Greek, that you get for non-baptized Christians.
There is a little bit of an overlap there. So anyway, the Auditors are the ones that don’t live as pious in the Manichaean sense of a lifestyle as the Elect. But they support them,and they hope, through reincarnation—even if they’re not saved right away—to become an Elect and then become saved. But in any case, there’s this two pronged reaction, I guess, to the idea that sexuality is inherently bad. So on the one hand, the Elect practice chastity, or at least they’re supposed to. And then on the other hand, the Auditors—it’s not like they’re puritanical. Well, they are obviously against sex, but the Auditors are not actually forbidden sex in general. They’re just enjoined to practice birth control, because what is bad about sex and the Manichaean view, at least primarily, is the reproductive aspect. So on the one hand, you have the Elects who are supposed to practice chastity. On the other hand, you have Auditors who are supposed to practice birth control. But in practice, from what we know, the Auditors might already have children when they become Manichaean, or they might have children anyway, even if the Elect says you should practice birth control. And it’s the Auditors who would’ve provided children, who would then become Elect. So that’s sort of the practical way in which the Manichaean community would’ve produced itself. Even if you follow the sexual ethics to their logical conclusion, it would disappear.
Shirley Paulson
I’m thinking that whenever we hear stories that are so far removed from the way we can comprehend or relate to anything, it sort of feels like, “Okay, this is just science fiction, or just somebody’s just imagining something.” But these are real people who thought this, and lived this way. Do you see any way that this story would’ve had a practical benefit? Does it make people live better or does it actually make good more prevalent in the lives of those who follow them? What does it do to real people?
Paul Dilley
Yeah, I mean, if you’re talking about practical benefits, there may have been benefits of being in a Manichaean community, which were quite unconnected to the specifics of the doctrine. Like any other group, they could have offered their members support in various ways. And in fact, the best evidence we have for a Manichaean community in Egypt in the Roman Empire is a town called Kellis, which is an oasis town in southern Egypt where there’ve been excavations, which have uncovered houses where you have Manichaean groups. And so you can see that they were Manichaean families and communities that supported each other in various ways. Now, as far as Manichaean ethics in general, beyond the sexual ethics, they had various commandments. The details of them are not 100% clear, but they had various seals: the seal of the eyes, or the seal of the mouth, et cetera.
But a sort of organizing principle where you’re supposed to regulate yourself and your emotions and your actions in a way that will not harm the light particle and do the most to just generally increase your own piety and those of others. Generally speaking though, the ethics were not vastly different from other Christian groups in terms of day-to-day interactions and avoiding bad actions or bad speech, or they also had a category for bad thoughts. The distinctive aspects of Manichaeaism were the kind of sexual ethics and how that plays out in the system with the Elect and the Catechumen, but also their ritual practice. So every week the Elects were brought certain vegetables from the Auditors that were thought to have a fairly large percentage of light particles in them. And so they would eat these vegetables and then pray and sing psalms afterwards. And the idea was that this was essentially a way of freeing the light particles and sending them up that cosmic highway back towards the Kingdom of Light. So I would argue the ritual practice, rather than the situational ethics, if you want to use that kind of language, that would’ve made the Manichaeans very distinctive.
Shirley Paulson
Distinctive for sure! Yes, so I get the feeling that the practice or the way their thoughts about things would make them want to be good, like they’re participating in the light, becoming liberated and free. So the humans are kind of needed to help the good win the war with the evil. Am I right?
Paul Dilley
Yes, absolutely. Yes. Okay.
Shirley Paulson
So, the humans can be helpful in the fight with good and evil.
Paul Dilley
Yes.
Shirley Paulson
Oh my goodness. Okay. So how widespread was this practice? I mean, I understand that there are two categories, and you described a geographic area. How did it connect, maybe with Christianity? You said that he was a Christian to start with, and he sort of brought in these other influences. What about the Eastern or the Western Christian groups? Did they get along or did they disagree? Did they like this idea of light particles? How did they deal with that?
Paul Dilley
Yeah, so in general, so Mani called himself the Apostle of Jesus Christ. So he saw his primary revealer figure as essentially a kind of manifestation of Jesus called Jesus the Splendor, who also, by the way, was the same person that at first manifested to Adam and taught him about the Kingdom of Light. So we definitely would’ve seen himself as Christian, in the sense of a follower of Christ. And in the Roman Empire, we have strong evidence that basically wherever the Manichaeans were, they called themselves Christians. So they saw themselves as the sort of the true Christians who have superseded Christians who had imperfect information that basically were not up to date with Mani’s revelation. So yeah, that was their self-identity, but they were not identified as such, of course, by their Christian opponents. So I would say right from the beginning, they were actually attacked. So the first people to attack them were not actually Christians. So Diocletian, the Roman emperor who is responsible for what’s called the Great Persecution of Christians, he also had an edict attacking the Manichaeans. And the first polemical treatise against them was actually by a Platonic philosopher, but the Christians kind of followed suit pretty quickly.
Shirley Paulson
Okay. So I want to try to understand a little bit about why others would be attacking. Were they harming others with their thoughts, or was it just that people didn’t like their ideas, or they weren’t causing any harm in society by not having more children, were they?
Paul Dilley
Actually we don’t even have any evidence to suggest that Auditors actually practiced birth control. So Augustine himself, when he was a Manichaean Auditor, he had a kid – out of wedlock, by the way. But in any case, it’s unclear to what extent their sexual ethics were actually practiced. It is fairly clear that the Elect would’ve been celibate, but the Auditor practice, it’s hard to say. So the Christians who attacked them were not really so concerned about the ongoing health of Roman society or anything like that, but simply they saw Mani’s revelation as an attack on their authority, which is I think, rightly so because he did claim that among other things that Christian scriptures have been tampered with, and he had the correct revelation, which superseded in much the same way that Christians of the time claimed that the New Testament superseded the Jewish scriptures, Mani is making very similar claims about the Christian scriptures being superseded. So yes, I mean, the knee-jerk reaction, of course, I mean, people like to get down and dirty with the doctrinal debates in any case. And so Mani, himself, I think would’ve been a particularly inviting target to Christian polemics, and indeed he was attacked from a fairly early period.
Shirley Paulson
Oh, okay. Well, you certainly have opened up a door of new thinking about a lot of new things here. And so we’re going to give everyone a chance to get to talk to you about this also. I see we have some questions already lined up in the chat, so we’ll get to those in a moment.
Alright, so let’s open to your questions and I think I’m going to start with the ones in the chat, and then if you want to have some more questions, raise your hand electronically. So I think Joy starts us off with asking how was the material world and Adam and Eve created?
Paul Dilley
So the material world was created. So after Primal Man was sent forth and was basically defeated and engulfed by the darkness, there were several other emanations, champions as it were from the Kingdom of Light that forged a counter attack and in turn chained various figures of the darkness up and created the cosmos essentially. And so the sun and the moon in particular were seen as these key points and the stage way back to the Kingdom of Light. So then what happened was, okay, so they set up this great mechanism for returning the light, so how are they going to get the light out? And the various accounts that we have are kind of fragmented and don’t necessarily tell the complete story. So just with that proviso in mind. But it seems like sexual difference was already a thing among the demons, as was basically lost.
And so a Manichaean, an emissary from the Kingdom of Light, appears in forms that were meant to evoke the lust of the male and the female demons. And so the idea is that after this appearance, the male demons ejaculated light particles and then the female demons aborted fetuses, and then the two chief demons consumed these and had sex with each other. And then, the female demon essentially gave birth to Adam and Eve. So Adam and Eve are sort of like—and this is what I mean by the creation of Adam and Eve as a kind of counter-stratagem of the Kingdom of Darkness—because they’ve been, in a sense, tricked into releasing their light through sexual excitement. And so they get it back by these two chief demons consuming it again. And then they in their own act of consummation, which as far as we know in the story, this is the first act of sexual reproduction. So in a sense, they kind of consecrate this act as a way to continue the entrapment of the light particles. And so they then reproduce a male and a female Adam and Eve.
Shirley Paulson
Wow, you were right. This is a complicated story.
Paul Dilley
Yes.
Shirley Paulson
Okay. So Adam and Eve were the product of this battle going on, but then humans ultimately are needed to be able to fight the battle to get the light particles free.
Paul Dilley
Very true, yes. So that is the interesting thing about it, because in many ways it seems absolutely pessimistic as far as the purpose of human existence. But on the other hand, humans, according to Mani do have free will, at least to an extent, and they are able to participate in this process of the freeing of the light.
Shirley Paulson
Well, this question came from Joy. Joy, do you want to keep going with this question here?
Joy Dryden
Yeah. So what I’m trying to get at is that it sounds like the Kingdom of Light was what produced the material world or humans and that the Kingdom of Darkness created Adam and Eve.
Paul Dilley
Yes, basically, so the kind of cosmic structure was on the initiative of the Kingdom of Light. And as you say, Adam and Eve were on the initiative of the Kingdom of Darkness. However, they were both happening in this new kind of material reality, which was the mixture of light and darkness. So the Manichaeans, think of three basic times. There’s the kind of initial time when light and darkness are separated. Then you have the current epoch where light and darkness are mixed, and basically the condition of the material world is this mixture of the light and the darkness, and that’s what accounts for our existence. So both the Kingdom of Light and the Kingdom of Darkness were working with this mixture. They were just at odds as far as what they wanted to do. The Kingdom of Darkness wanted to keep the light, so it wants to keep things mixed. The Kingdom of darkness wants to return the light and get back to the third age, which is separation again.
Shirley Paulson
It’s so interesting to think in terms of dualism, telling us that there’s a Kingdom of good and evil coexisting, and you’ve got to have both going at the same time, when dualism is such, I think, a problem in Christian thought. That’s interesting.
Thanks for that. Great question, Joy. So next we have Sujan. I can read your question or you can either speak up for yourself. I’m going to read what you have, and then you can also add on if we didn’t cover it correctly. But Sujan is asking, is the idea of freeing the particles of light related to the Kabbalistic philosophy of Isaac Luria?
Paul Dilley
No, not directly, but certainly there is a kind of broader tradition of what’s often thought of as a kind of gnostic worldview in which the Manichaeans are sometimes positioned as at least a related entity. So it’s not out of the question, perhaps, that they might’ve read similar things, but in general, the Isaac Luria—or the Kabbalistic tradition—would have wholly rejected the idea that they’re based on Manichaean traditions or something like that.
Sujan Burgeson
What it kind of made me think about is your story of eating the vegetables because Luria believed that the whole world is created when there’s this shattering of the vessel of light and all the particles get trapped in the material world, and our purpose here is to free them. So even if you eat a strawberry, you could do that with the idea that you’re freeing the light, and then when the light is all restored, then the kingdom of God is established. So it sounds kind of related to the vegetables and eating the vegetables and offering the particles of light.
Paul Dilley
Yeah, no doubt! So I’m not discounting the notion that they are very… Well, it’s possible that Isaac was familiar with, say, a clinical account against the Manichaeans and drew some form of inspiration there. So you definitely have a kind of longstanding exchange of ideas that would’ve basically traveled along by ways that we can’t reconstruct anymore. But the major difference is also the fact that there weren’t Elects doing a ritual meal to sort of free these light particles. So it’s the kind of reality of the community that I think shows that there’s basically fundamental differences.
Sujan Burgeson
Just wanted to thank Paul, because there’s so many resonances that we can find in many different traditions that pick up the same symbolism.
Shirley Paulson
And I think it’s so intriguing to think about how people really wrestled with things we don’t have answers for still today. I mean, we don’t know how much life is in a plant, or how much goodness is in a plant, or how much evil is in a human. All these questions we’re still wrestling with! So I think these are really interesting questions and ways to think about things we haven’t even thought about.
I’m moving to Pat in the chat.. Pat says, “Did the Manichaean sense of chastity provide an interpretation that was picked up by Catholic clergy later on? And then did Mani actually write the documents that we have from his movement? Or, like the Christian Gospels, were they written by apostles or by others?”
Paul Dilley
So I’ll answer them in sequence. So the Manichaeans were early ascetics among Christian groups. They definitely weren’t the first Christian ascetics. In fact, one of the primary groups and early Christian literatures that Mani would’ve been familiar with was called Encratite Christianity, which also places an emphasis on chastity, including at least among some groups, the idea that anyone who was baptized should not be having sex. And you see there this kind of connection between the Manichaean Catechumens versus the Elects. So Mani was definitely not the first Christian to practice chastity, and he was also overshadowed perhaps soon after by more famous ascetics, like Antony of Egypt, for example. Coming back to the figure of Augustine. One of the ways in which he was slowly drawn away from Manichaeism was reading about the Christian ascetic, Anthony. So I wouldn’t say, and it took a while for there to be an idea that Christian presbyters in particular, but even also bishops had to practice celibacy.
So that was a kind of longer and disputed thing. The Manichaeans might have been one example of a group where the ritual Elite practice chastity, but probably they were not the primary group that Christians were looking to as they were debating this question as to whether priests should be chaste?
And the other question is actually quite important to Manichaean doctrines. So the Manichaeans said that unlike Jesus, Zoroaster, and Buddha, Mani actually wrote his own scriptures. So he had a revelation, he wrote it down. We know of approximately seven works of his, and they were circulated, and as the community spread, they translated into numerous different languages. So the idea that their own founder was also the author of his own writings, as it were, kind of gave it a newness, a difference from previous revelations and including the Christian revelation.
Shirley Paulson
It’s fascinating to think about what a difference it is that Jesus and Zoroastor and Buddha didn’t write anything down, and what does that mean? Very interesting. Okay, so Pat, anymore you want to add on to that?
Pat Nester
Oh, I was interested in this anti-sex fascination that developed during that period. Did they have venereal disease or something? Was there some practical consequence of sexuality that plugged into these doctrines?
Paul Dilley
Well, so the issue was that people did practice birth control, but that was not tied to avoiding venereal disease or anything like that. That certainly wasn’t the motivation for that kind of sexual ethics. It’s an interesting question, but not at all.
Shirley Paulson
Interesting. Okay, so I think Sarah’s next.
Sara Barnacle
I hear the word ‘elect’, and I think of the word ‘elect’ in the Bible, especially in the Old Testament, and they seem like two, sort of different, things. Like in the Old Testament, it always seems like God is choosing an elect, and it sounds like in Manichaeism, it’s sort of like self-chosen, maybe. Could you talk about that?
Paul Dilley
That’s a great question. The term ‘elect’ isn’t really… It’s sort of taken for granted, but its broader significance, I think, really could be explored more fully. I would imagine most likely what’s going on is that it refers to Mani’s chosen disciples. But he had a group of 12 disciples—sound familiar—but in any case, they were a special group. And then beyond that, there were even more Elect. But I think the idea is still very much the same. They’re the kind of community elite that have been chosen by Mani or by God, via proxy.
Sara Barnacle
Well, and you mentioned a city that had been unearthed down in Egypt in a place like that.
Paul Dilley
A village, really.
Sara Barnacle
A village. Okay, a village. But would the Elect and the others kind of live side by side? Would the community be mixed like that, or did they have a separation? Do you know?
Paul Dilley
Yeah, so the Elect, in theory, were actually supposed to be mobile. So they weren’t supposed to settle in any community for any extended length of time. They were supposed to be itinerant, kind of like the early disciples of Jesus are imagined to have been – kind of wandering from community to community.
And Kellis—which shows how widespread potentially the Manichaeans were, because I mean, this is really literally a backwater oasis town of Egypt—and yet they had a fairly vibrant Manichaean community in the fourth century. So as far as we know, most of the Manichaeans identified in the letters from Kellis were Auditors. There’s a letter to a traveling Elect, but he’s going up and down the Nile. So that at least does kind of check out this idea that the Elect would’ve been on the move pretty regularly. What we know from Augustine’s writings on the Manichaeans also suggests that the big important Manichaeans of North Africa, like Faustus or Augustine, had to wait for him to arrive to really ask him the questions that he wanted. So that seems to have been a pretty stable pattern.
Sara Barnacle
Thank you.
Shirley Paulson
What interesting questions we’re having tonight! These are wonderful. Thank you everybody.
I’m going to keep going. So Clare also brings up a really interesting point here. I’m going to read Clare’s thing, and again, Claire, if you have something to add to that, please do. She says, “I’m so accustomed to the idea that light naturally takes over darkness. Darkness doesn’t have a chance. So this is tricky to imagine light and darkness fighting, or maybe is this metaphorical?”
Paul Dilley
Well, it’s definitely not supposed to be metaphorical. The Manichaeans were kind of literalist materialists. So the idea was that the escape of the light is describing an actual physical process. So they did, however, believe that ultimately the Kingdom of Light had the upper hand. First of all, physically, it was located above the Kingdom of Darkness. And it often talked about how the surrender—the seeming victory of the Kingdom of Light—that it gets at the very beginning of the struggle, where it kind of overtakes primal man, was actually a trap set by the Kingdom of Light, a kind of temporary loss on the way to the plan of eventually fully recovering all of the light particles. And they were quite confident in their teachings about the end of the world, where the idea was that eventually all of the particles would be saved except for a remnant, which would kind of get—unfortunately for it—stuck in a ball. Limbo is not the right word for it; it’s just eternal damnation, shall we say. But then beyond that, the kingdom of light is back to its former self. So it’s like the Kingdom of Light’s victory is never in doubt, but it also loses. It definitely suffers loss as a result of this conflict.
Shirley Paulson
Oh my goodness, what a strange kind of light this is. Okay, so Clare, do you want to add onto this in any way?
Clare Turner
Well, I appreciated Maureen’s clearer statement of my question that the darkness is the absence of light. But I think your explanation is helpful. I am just stuck in that!
Paul Dilley
Yeah, well, I mean, that’s a good point too, right? That’s how we tend to think of it. But the Manichaeans actually thought of darkness not as the absence of light, but a material thing, an opposition to the light.
Clare Turner
Okay, well, it feels like that in life sometimes too.
Shirley Paulson
Claire, I think what you’re saying is really important to us because I think we can sort of reason one way, but then we seem to experience something else. And I feel like these ancient struggles we’re dealing with are like the way the human experience is going. So how do you find explanations for these things, even if they don’t make sense? That’s why I think that these stories often feel like they don’t make sense to us, but they’re trying to deal with things that were really happening. So I think these questions are just wonderful. They really do relate to the issues.
I need to move along here. So Sujan says,” Were they related in any way to the Cathars?”
Paul Dilley
So possibly, just possibly, as with Isaac Luria, it’s possible that some of the Cathars had read, say, Augustine’s anti-Manichaean polemic, and picked up some ideas there. It’s just not entirely out of the question that they maybe even had a Manichaean text that had survived. I don’t want to reject any of that out of hand. We also don’t have a bunch of Cathar writing either. We don’t have the full story for any of this. At the same time, however, it’s also true that because the Manichaeans’ sort of the archetypal heresy, they often were used… The term ‘Manichaean’ was used as basically an insult to any kind of heretics—so especially those like the Cathars, that might be espousing a kind of dualism. So the Cathars were sometimes labeled as Manichaean, but that might be just as much of polemical move as an accurate reflection of how they got their ideas. But certainly, it’s often rejected out of hand that they had any access to the Manichaeans. I think it’s possible that they might’ve had some kind of familiarity, direct or indirect. But again, it’s the question of “Did they take that in the same way, replicate their structure? Did they have a meal for freeing the light particles? This Elect-Catechumen dichotomy?” And so there it runs up against the reality that there’s not a strict historical continuity.
Shirley Paulson
That’s fascinating. So Toto, what are you thinking about?
Toto Tay
I’m trying to remember… I just remembered when you guys were talking about objective light and darkness, didn’t they have a, was it the Arzhang, or a book of illustration, that Manichaean painted?
Yeah, that showed kind of how it worked? And my question about that was, “How much would something like that do you think would be attributed to the legs growing out so much? Because, he was crossing multiple languages and everything else… I’m always surprised that doesn’t happen more, that more illustrative stuff that crosses language barriers isn’t used.
Paul Dilley
Yeah. So he did have, I’ve mentioned that he is credited as a scribe, so he wrote his own works. He also has a picture book, which was an accompaniment to his revelation, probably the living Gospel. And yeah, my colleague has a recent book-length study where she tries to reconstruct what we know about the picture book and puts it in dialogue with traditions of didactic instruction with illustrations, and especially in Central and East Asia, because that’s where the Manichean evidence that survives is from. But there’s a longstanding Buddhist tradition of that, for example. And as I mentioned at the outset, that’s one of the interesting things about Manichaeans, is that, yes, it’s this Jewish Christian tradition that forms the major stream. But then there’s a lot of interaction with the Zoroastrian, especially to a lesser extent, but still a significant one with Buddhism and other South Asian religions.
Shirley Paulson
Wow. Thank you for that question, Toto.
Honor Haase
What I’m hearing is that the Manichaeans were very interested in following their view of human morals. And either you called Mani a Christian apostle or you quoted somebody else as referring to him as such. So I’m just wondering if they’re thought of as Christian or not. What I hear in Jesus’ teaching is a great emphasis on God and the Father, and I don’t hear anything like that, so far, about the Manichaens. Am I missing something?
Paul Dilley
Yeah, fair question. So Mani did call himself an Apostle of God and the Father of Lights, who is the sort of prime entity in the Kingdom of Light, which is the sort of what would be the Manichaean equivalent to what Christians often called “God the Father.”
Honor Haase
So they recognize that there is a God, but there doesn’t seem to be a lot of stress on teaching about God.
Paul Dilley
It’s hard to say, really, because we don’t have that many Manichaean sources. Some of the sources that we do have in the Psalms do address the Father. They also address other aspects of the Father, like Jesus. But of course, so do Christians. So definitely I take your point that there’s much more of an emphasis perhaps, on the Kingdom of Light, as opposed to the Father of Lights. Although in Jesus’s teaching and the canonical gospels, there’s a lot of importance set on the Kingdom of Heaven. So Mani probably would’ve argued that his kind of description of the land of Light was basically just kind of adding some detail to gospel passages on the Kingdom of Heaven.
Shirley Paulson
Oh, thank you so much. And we have one last quick thing here from Pat: “Were the light particles analogous to the atoms postulated by Democrites, don’t even know how to say his name, the basic ingredients that matter, or were they purely spiritual?”
Paul Dilley
Yeah, they were very much physical. The Platonists were; Democrites wasn’t a Platonist, but certainly part of a much longer chain of Hellenistic and later platonic philosophy. Yeah, so Mani was a materialist. So that’s part of the reason why the first person to write against him, that survives, was actually what we would call a middle platonic philosopher, an Egyptian middle.
Shirley Paulson
Oh my gosh. I think you can tell. We have a lot of questions left, Paul. We could be with you for a few more hours that we don’t have time for.
Paul Dilley
Well, it’s been a pleasure to have all very good questions. Thank you.
Shirley Paulson
This is so much fun. We really appreciate you coming to open this window for us. Really appreciate you being there. Well, I have to say that I knew it would be an exciting topic. I’m so glad people came to hear it, and you know that it’ll be archived.
And this was the April, 2025 Bible and Beyond discussion titled “The Manichaean Story of Adam and Eve,” with our guest scholar, Dr. Paul Dilley. We’re glad you’ve joined us for our once a month Bible and Beyond discussions on Monday nights from 8pm to 9pm Eastern time. We usually meet on the fourth Monday of the month. But again, not next month, either due to Memorial Day, we’ll need to meet on Monday, May 19th.
Each Bible and Beyond Discussion is led by a knowledgeable scholar who provides a thoughtful overview of the text and creates an opportunity for participants to ask their own questions.
And now, please join me in a big thanks to Paul for coming to be with us tonight. So grateful to you, Paul. I really appreciate it. We’ll be in touch again. Thanks so much.
Paul Dilley
Sounds good. Take care.



Thank you Shirley for hostessing these discussions and allowing those of us that missed the original event to tap into it later. I did have one question: were there female elect/elites? With the Manichaean negative views of sex, and the perhaps difficulty of women traveling alone (because the elect were peripatetic) – did this make it difficult for women to achieve an elect status?
Hello Helen, there were female elect; your insights about the difficulties they faced are correct.
Really interesting!